Grave

But then it nearly require you to have ACC bonus to deal non-crit damage, which to some people that's a really hard hit. 

Eh... you haz point.

It makes sense in context, but it would remove a lot of functionality from the cooking profession. The evasion debuff is already rather debilitating in certain circumstances, and when you compare it to alchemists who can not only craft the same amount of damage increase but can also put it in a crystal to be used instantaneously, on top of that profession already having a lot of functionality, it kinda furthers that gap. Cooks are more or less the buffing profession, and removing accuracy instead of evasion would probably just nullify the enhancement entirely.

also the fisherman profession is dumb and shouldn't exist. they're just less efficient cooks.