Amira

So staff can't retroactively enforce rules, except for when it benefits them in some way? Tristans actions in gaining those items and distributing them was not, in fact, against the rules. So please dont try to say that because it just makes you look like a hypocrite.

A true compromise leaves niether side happy, and having other players create vanity items to replace those items is unacceptable. That replacement "Blackfyre Cloak" was not Zelrius' cloak that he had in character. Neither would this vanity Commandants Pendant be. By replacing them with these fakes you would be taking Tristan's characters actions and making them completely out of character. His charcater doesnt seem like the sort to get fakes made of a friends items to give to others. Just making that side point.

Once again, retroactively enforcing a rule isnt something that staff should be able to do. And if they can, this isnt a place i'd want to be. If I wasnt trying so hard to point out the contradictory actions of the staff, or to make this point, i would suggest that only the items that the deceased had on would vanish. (Which would include the pendant) However, that would still require them to retroactively enforce a rule that they came up with quite a while after the fact.

Before anyone tries to say that this is just me trying to get a unique item, no matter the decision of staff, i wont be keeping the pendant.  Obviously if staff decides to continue retroactively enforcing this rule, i wont get it. But if they stop and I get it, ill be giving it away in order to keep people from trying to invalidate my argument by saying it's "greed".   

P.S. I fully expect a reply here giving me an official warning, this status to be locked, and maybe even deleted. If so it will just prove to me that staff knows that what their doing is wrong and against their own rules and is choosing to ignore that.

P.P.S. That isnt a threat, just the statement of a fact.